Anonymous June 14, 2009 at 3:53 pm Reply I like the detail in this report."fish in acid filled water" VERY INTERESTING.What lures were catching the fish,? Spoons? Cool looking hat.Chuck in Toronto
Andy Lewis June 14, 2009 at 5:26 pm Reply Very interesting post. There was a time I thought you really needed to have downriggers to pursue trout. It's a great technique. However, applying lessons learned on Eagle Lake where Trout can be caught as deep as 100' with a 3-way rig with 6 ounces of lead, I have learned this isn't the case. I may get some down riggers some day, but yesterday I fished cohos for the first time on Saturday morning on Lake Michigan. I tried some 3-way rigs, dipsy diver, lead core and flat lines. I only caught 2 cohos with a few bumps, but both came on lead core rigs with 6 colors of lead core line in 100' of water (about 30' down). Both hit a peanut fly behind an orange flasher. In the fall, the fish on Eagle Lake will be very deep but can be reached with 6 ounces of lead. I have been wondering, and will likely try, a flasher rig this fall. No…I'm not talking about the Professor. I have no doubt the down rigger setup with a few stick baits might have caught a few more hog walleyes as well? Acidity could be impacting the fishery, but all I can say is that those trout holes have been very good to a few professors I know in the fall. If they were acidic in the spring, I would assume they were acidic in the fall. Let's hope for the best and assume that the lake trout population is just getting more healthy and anglers are doing a better job of releasing big trout? I think the trout simply move to where the bait fish and warmer water are.
Perchmaster June 14, 2009 at 9:25 pm Reply That is an interesting observation on the spring trout, guess will have to see what happens in 2010, maybe he has something there.
Professor June 15, 2009 at 5:23 pm Reply A small, but important correction to Andy's post.We actually used 8 ounces of lead to get us down to the trout (70 feet and deeper). Plus, we had about 225-275 feet of 14 pound FireLine out. Doctor Spoons in silver and the Williams Wabbler in silver/gold have produced lakers up to 38 inches for us in Trout Hole # 1 and # 2 for us during the past three years. And we hope to hear our reels sing again this August.
Gord June 15, 2009 at 6:42 pm Reply There are two advantages I can see using down riggers over the three way swivel. First, you only end up fighting the fish, not the fish and 8 oz. of lead….plus all the intervening hardware. Second, since the downriggers basically have your baits straight down off the back of the boat it is far easier to make quick turns and get closer to structure without worrying about a big tangle of lines. This is not to say I am going to run out and get downriggers…..I still like the simple techniques. One thing that Pete and Ken used was two spoons on each line. They used "sliders" which is basically a piece of gas line tubing over a barrel swivel through which the main line passed through. Using a needle to puncture the tubing the main line went through each wall of the tube and one end of the swivel, which is inside. The result is the swivel, leader material and spoon is held in place at whatever height on the main line but in the event of a strike it would slide down to the bottom hook. This could be done using the three way swivel approach as well.
Perchmaster June 15, 2009 at 10:03 pm Reply OK Gus one problem here and anyone that has fished with you will know this to be true, with your SHARP turns forget it you will tangle specially using sliders off those lines.Gold/silver sutton spoons always was a great bait on lake Michigan but then again lake trout like it flashy, also something to try with be a dodger/fly combo
STEVE SANDBERG - LIBERTYVILLE IL June 15, 2009 at 11:05 pm Reply I HAVE FISHED L.TROUT ON EAGLE OFF AND ON FOR SOME 20 YRS AND FOUND THAT ALTHOUGH YOU CAN ON OCCASSION GET BIGGER FISH UP HIGH, THE BIGGER FISH TEND TO COME WITHIN 10FT OF THE BOTTOM. TRY SOME LARGE SPINNERS OR SILVER DODGERS WITH A TRAILING HAIR FLY OR SMALLER SPOON. GOOD LUCK
Steve Sandberg June 15, 2009 at 11:07 pm Reply Does anyone have a recent water temp?. Thanks for the info.
Gord June 15, 2009 at 11:37 pm Reply Hi Steve! Things are warming up quick. Temps are in the low 60's, water temps that is. Starting to see some limited weed growth. Quite a few large muskies have been sighted this week by walleye guys……I think they are spawning or have just finished. Weather has improved…summer is here. Good point on the lake trout.
Gord June 17, 2009 at 1:21 pm Reply Temperature update……water temps are in the upper 60's with some warm patches in the 70's. This has come a long way since Saturday when the water was in the mid to upper 50 degree range.
STEVE SANDBERG June 17, 2009 at 7:27 pm Reply THANKS FOR THE WATER TEMP UPDATE. WE KNOW HOW THE SKIS LIKE THAT WARMER WATER. SEE YA NEXT WEEKEND
